Last week, I debuted #hpcsmchat, a Twitter-based chat where we discuss social media issues. The inaugural chat focused on the evolution of Twitter’s like button (formerly known as the favourite button) becoming a primary means of engagement.
In the 8 years I’ve been on Twitter, I’ve noticed a lot of changes. Hashtags didn’t exist when I signed up, and it seemed to be used more as a way to chat with friends.
Since then, hashtags of emerged, and retweets were introduced, now a popular method of sharing information on Twitter. Sharing has become a much more central tenet of Twitter usage.
The like button has been a great example of the evolution of Twitter. In the beginning, Twitter users typically used it as a bookmark feature. Today, it fills a multitude of purposes.
Tom Albrighton of ABC Copywriting had this to say about some of those uses:
@hotpepper Sometimes you want to acknowledge a sentiment, maybe something personal, without broadcasting it to your network
— Tom Albrighton (@tomcopy) March 14, 2015
@hotpepper It's not even engagement sometimes. It's just a way to end the conversation politely
— Tom Albrighton (@tomcopy) March 14, 2015
Clearly, the Twitter like button serves a purpose, but my issue with the button isn’t that it has no purpose. My issue is that it’s become a substitute for the retweet, and I think that threatens engagement.
One of the reasons the like button appears to be gaining popularity is that I think people see it as a tool similar to the Facebook like. Award-winning marketer Helen Hesk of Melon Communications agrees.
@hotpepper some tweeters favourite as though it's a like on Facebook post but it works in a totally different way
— Helen Hesk ? (@helenhesk) March 14, 2015
As the practice of using the like button as a like has become more popular, we see more likes and fewer retweets on content we share. Favouriting instead of retweeting is a poor way to engage with people.
The person whose tweet you likes receives notification, but no one else does. It doesn’t tell your followers that you liked it, nor does it give the original tweeter the courtesy of sharing his/her tweet to show that you liked it.
Retweets, on the other hand, tell your followers that you thought the content was good enough to share it with them. That’s how jazz pianist John Kan feels.
https://twitter.com/KanMan251/status/576845997252427776
In fact, if your followers never see your likes, what purpose is served to like a tweet as a sign that you liked it? Or as Mary Wright of Mary Wright Design Ltd said, why not just retweet it?
@hotpepper I have. Always makes me think 'so why don't you retweet it?' ?
— Mary Wright (@mrsmarywright) March 14, 2015
Just this week, one of the tweets I sent out received more than double the number of RTs it had. Clearly, people liked it, but just not enough to retweet it.
Maybe people don’t want to commit to a retweet, for some reason, and a like allows them to engage without committing. That seems lazy to me and the opposite of what social media is. After all, it’s called social media for a reason.
Liking isn’t social at all. It doesn’t share anything with your followers and outside of simply looking at a tweet, it’s the weakest form of engagement possible on a tweet.
As I said, it does serve a purpose (to bookmark, politely end a conversation, a nod to someone else’s thank you, and so on), but the trend towards it’s becoming the primary engagement method of Twitter is discouraging.
As I said recently, just retweeting is hardly engaging, but it’s certainly better than just liking, and at least your followers see it.
What do you think? Let me know in the comments below.
I agree entirely – the favourite button is definitely an anti-social aspect of social media.
The issue is that it’s so ubiquitous. I tend to use the favourite button as a bookmark (I’m old-school like that), so I will check back to see what’s in my favourites tab and clear out some of the older or irrelevant content. In that way, it does provide some value to my followers as they can pop in and see what I find useful.
But for some people, it’s almost a read receipt button. For example, one of the hockey bloggers I follow has over 23,000 favourites as he tags every Tweet he’s mentioned in. That, to me, renders the whole thing useless.
Then again, it’s par for the course on Twitter. Hashtags used to be a way of tracking conversations, now they’re somewhere between a subject line and a witty aside. And don’t get me started on the decline of Follow Friday…
Absolutely, it’s a ubiquitous feature with various uses and features. My point though is that it becomes problematic when it is one’s only interactions with others’ tweets.
I don’t favorite tweets to engage with them. I absolutely use it as a bookmarking system. In some cases, for when I have more time to reply later and not be rushed, or to save a link I want to check out.
I will definitely RT the tweet later, unless I favourited it for a personal reason and would rather not broadcast why (family members illness, for example).
In Tweetdeck, you can see who favorited your tweet, so that’s a nice acknowledgement, and sometimes gives me a reason to engage with them and start a conversation, but it’s not forced.
And that, I think, is the original reason for the feature, Kevin. :)