The following is a reader submission.
The argument is whether dwindle makes sense on the following sentence:
Mrs. Jones, please dwindle down the invitation list.
Both sides of the argument agree that dwindle makes sense in the following sentence:
His finances dwindled down due to his overspending.
We aren’t looking for what sounds best, but whether it is grammatically correct. Please offer an explanation along with your answer.
This has become a major office debate, please help.
Thanks!
Christina
Hi Christina,
Unfortunately, you’re on the wrong side of the debate. Both usages are correct. :)
I consulted five dictionaries, and they all say the verb “to dwindle” can actually be both transitive (i.e. Dwindle the invitation list) and intransitive (i.e. His finances dwindled).
I should point out that accompanying “dwindle” with “down” is redundant since “dwindle’ means a reduction, which “down” implies.
I hope that helps, and sorry it wasn’t in your favour.
Kim
Email me your grammar questions. I’ll be sure to post the question and answer here.
Good call on the redundant “down”. I was going to point that out as I read the top part, but then I noticed that you caught it already.
Thanks for keeping your eye out, Ben.
Nice blog! I just stumbled upon your blog today. Will be following it from now on!:)